Gifts for the Fly Fisherman Who Has Everything

The best gift for a fly fisherman who has everything is an upgrade to something they use on every trip but wouldn't buy for themselves: premium nippers, a pair of machined pliers, a good pair of leather gloves or a travel case. Our picks run from $147 to $389.95 and you can see them all on our site. Don't replace the rod or reel they love. Upgrade the small things around it.

Anyone who has fished for years owns a rod they trust and a reel they'd never sell. What they usually still carry is a worn-out pair of nippers, a pair of pliers they've had for a decade or a pair of gloves with a hole in them. That's where a gift lands.

In brief

  • Upgrade the tools they use every trip: nippers, pliers, gloves and a travel case.
  • Gifts in this guide run from $147 to $389.95.
  • Skip anything that replaces a rod or reel they already love.
  • Not sure? A gift card lets them choose.

What is a good gift for a fisherman who has everything?

Look for the thing they use constantly and have never upgraded. Tools are the best place to start, because they're the items an angler is least likely to buy for themselves.

Gift Price Why it works for someone who has everything
Hatch Nippers $147.00 Tungsten carbide cutters and a needle post for cleaning fly eyelets
Filson Original Lined Goatskin Gloves $150.00 Grade A goatskin from the USA with a winged thumb for full movement
Abel Pliers $350.00 Machined in the USA with user-replaceable jaws, and a cutter and anvil that rotate 180 degrees
Hatch Nomad 2 Pliers $375.00 A premium plier from Hatch, the same maker as the nippers above
Van Staal Pliers $389.95 A heavy-duty plier built for saltwater and freshwater

Why are premium nippers a good gift?

Every angler cuts line all day, and most carry whatever nippers they bought years ago. The Hatch Nippers are $147 and are made from 6061-T6 aluminum with tungsten carbide cutters. They have a needle post for cleaning eyelets on small flies and come with a custom lanyard. They're a luxury version of a tool the angler already uses every day.

Hatch Nippers

See every option in our nippers collection.

Why are pliers worth the splurge?

Pliers are the tool most anglers use for years without upgrading. The Abel Pliers are $350 and made in the USA. The cutter and anvil rotate 180 degrees, which gives the angler a fresh cutting edge and doubles its life, and the jaws are user-replaceable. They come with a leather sheath and a carabiner. Colors and finishes change, and some pairs are one-offs, so ask us what we have in stock before you buy.

Abel Pliers with leather sheath

We also carry the Hatch Nomad 2 at $375 and the Van Staal Pliers at $389.95. See all five in our pliers collection.

What about gifts that aren't tools?

A few ideas that suit someone who already owns the basics:

Filson Original Lined Goatskin Gloves

Should you buy a rod or reel for the angler who has everything?

Only if you know exactly what they want. A rod and reel are personal, and a fly angler who has everything has already chosen theirs. If you're set on a big gift, talk to us first. Our usual advice is the newest model from the brand they already fish, though we may not have it on the shelf yet, so check with us before you order. We can look at the rod they fish and suggest a reel or a second rod that complements it. Browse our fly rods and fly reels, and read our guide to premium fly rods if you want to learn what sets Scott, Sage and Winston apart.

What should you skip?

  • Gadgets with a novelty angle. Experienced anglers already have a system, and a gimmick usually ends up in a drawer.
  • Flies in a gift box. An angler who has everything picks flies for the water in front of them.
  • Clothing that needs a size. Skip it unless you know the size or the style they like.

What if you can't decide?

Buy a gift card. Our digital gift cards email the recipient instantly, so they can choose the upgrade they've been putting off. Gift card purchases are non-refundable.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good gift for a fisherman who has everything?

An upgrade to a tool they use every trip, such as premium nippers ($147), machined pliers ($350 to $389.95) or leather gloves ($150). They're things anglers rarely buy for themselves.

What are some unusual fishing gifts?

Premium pliers are a good place to start. The colors and finishes on our Abel and Hatch pliers change, so ask us what's in stock. A good rod case or a pair of Filson gloves are other gifts anglers don't often buy for themselves.

What do you buy a fly fisherman who has everything under $200?

The Hatch Nippers at $147 or the Filson Original Lined Goatskin Gloves at $150. Both are premium versions of something they already use.

Should I buy a fly rod as a gift?

Only if you know exactly which rod they want. Fly rods are personal, so if you aren't sure, choose a tool or a gift card instead. If you do buy one, the newest model from the brand they already fish is the safest pick.

Keep shopping

Buying on a tighter budget? See Fly Fishing Gifts Under $100: What We Actually Put in Stockings. Shopping for someone new to the sport? Read Fly Fishing Gifts for Beginners: What to Buy and What to Skip. Or browse our fly boxes, tools and accessories, and holler at us in Atlanta if you'd like help choosing.