Fly Fishing Gifts Under $100: What We Actually Put in Stockings

The best fly fishing gifts under $100 are the small things an angler uses on every trip and never buys for themselves: nippers, a retractor to hang them on, a fly box that holds flies tight, and a warm hat. Every pick below is $34.95 or less, so you can fill a whole stocking and still land under $100.
Prices are what we list on our site at the time of writing. We're a fly shop in Atlanta, so these are the things we'd tell a friend to grab.
In brief
- The best fly fishing gifts under $100 are nippers, retractors, fly boxes and hats, from $19.95 to $34.95 each.
- A full stocking of one nipper, one fly box, one retractor and one watch cap comes to $99.85.
- Duplicates are welcome. Anglers lose nippers and always need another fly box.
- Not sure what they own? A gift card emails to them instantly.

What are the best fly fishing gifts under $100?
The best ones are tools and storage. They get used on every outing, and they go missing or wear out often enough that a spare is never wasted. Here is what we'd put in a stocking, with the price on our site today.
| Gift | Price | Why they'll use it |
|---|---|---|
| Fishpond 360 Swivel Retractor | $19.95 | Clips nippers or pliers to a pack or vest and swivels so the tool stays within reach |
| Fish Hawk Double Sided Waterproof Fly Box (Small) | $21.99 | A waterproof, two-sided box for the flies that don't fit in the main one |
| Simms Freestone Nipper | $24.95 | A straightforward nipper for trimming tippet and tag ends |
| Fishpond Tacky Original Fly Box | $24.95 | Holds up to 168 flies in a silicone pad that grips hooks and doesn't absorb water |
| Simms Black Zinger | $24.95 | A carabiner-style retractor for nippers, hemostats and other small tools |
| Filson Ballard Watch Cap | $30.00 | Itch-free, quick-drying warmth for cold mornings on the water |
| Simms Everyday Waffle Knit Beanie | $34.95 | A waffle-knit beanie for winter days on the river |
| The Fish Hawk Classic Rope Hat | $34.95 | Our own rope hat, for the angler who likes to carry a little of the shop with them |
Most of these live in our fly boxes, tools and accessories collection, and the hats are in headwear.
How do you build a stocking for $50, $75 or $100?
Start with a nipper and a fly box, then add pieces until you hit your number. These three builds use the prices in the table above.
- A $50 stocking comes to $49.90: the Simms Freestone Nipper and the Fishpond Tacky Original Fly Box.
- A $75 stocking comes to $69.85: add the Fishpond 360 Swivel Retractor, so the nipper has a home on their pack or vest.
- A $100 stocking comes to $99.85: add the Filson Ballard Watch Cap for cold mornings.
Want to compare options side by side? Browse our nippers and retractors collections.
Why are nippers and retractors such good gifts?
Every angler cuts line dozens of times a day, and nippers are small enough to drop in a river or leave on a tailgate. A retractor keeps them on a tether, so a nipper and a retractor work best as a pair.

The Simms Freestone Nipper is $24.95 and does the job without any fuss. For the tether, the Fishpond 360 Swivel Retractor is $19.95, and the Simms Black Zinger is $24.95 and clips on with a carabiner, which suits packs and bags.
If the angler already carries a fancy pair, skip these and see our guide to gifts for the fly fisherman who has everything.
Which fly box should you buy?
A fly box is the one gift an angler can't have too many of, because every trip calls for a different set of flies. The Fishpond Tacky Original Fly Box is $24.95. Its silicone pad holds up to 168 flies, doesn't absorb water, and the clear lid lets them see what's inside. Our own double-sided waterproof box in the small size is $21.99.

Browse every option in our fly boxes collection.
Are hats and beanies a safe gift?
Mostly yes. A warm cap is an easy win in December, and it's easier to get right than waders or a jacket. We carry the Filson Ballard Watch Cap at $30.00, the Simms Everyday Waffle Knit Beanie at $34.95 and The Fish Hawk Classic Rope Hat at $34.95.

See all of them in headwear.
What should you skip under $100?
- A multi-tool that claims to do five jobs. One good nipper beats it.
- A random fly assortment. Flies are chosen for the water, and a box of the wrong patterns ends up in a drawer.
- Anything with a size, like waders, boots or a jacket, unless you already know it.
What if you don't know what they already own?
Buy a gift card. Our digital gift cards email the recipient instantly, which makes them a good last-minute pick. Gift card purchases are non-refundable, so choose the amount you mean.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good fly fishing gift under $100?
Nippers, a fly box, a retractor or a warm hat. On our site they run from $19.95 to $34.95, they get used on every trip, and a nipper plus a fly box comes to $49.90.
What does every fly fisherman need?
Every fly fisherman needs a rod, reel, line, leader and flies, plus a few small tools: nippers to cut line, a fly box to carry flies and a retractor to keep the tools close. Those small tools are the easiest gifts to buy because they work with whatever rod the angler owns.
What should I get someone who likes fly fishing?
If you don't know their gear, buy something that works with any setup: nippers, a fly box or a cap. If you want to spend more, a premium pair of pliers or nippers is the next step up.
What can I put in a fly fisherman's stocking?
A nipper, a retractor, a fly box and a watch cap all fit in a stocking and come to $99.85 together. Swap the cap for a second fly box if they already have a hat.
Keep shopping
Want to spend more? See Gifts for the Fly Fisherman Who Has Everything. Buying for someone new to the sport? Read Fly Fishing Gifts for Beginners: What to Buy and What to Skip.
Or browse everything in our fly boxes, tools and accessories collection, and stop by the shop in Atlanta if you'd rather pick it out in person.